Wednesday, June 2, 2010
Ecosystem based management meets planning: South Carolina case study
The David and Lucile Packard Foundation has funded PlaceMatters* to run three pilot projects, with the purpose of combining ecosystem-based management (EBM) tools within traditional planning.
Three counties in South Carolina are approaching planning in a new way: the Berkeley-Charleston-Dorchester region is using new methods to assess their vulnerability to natural hazards, resource conservation, and socioeconomic factors. This analysis will then shape the BCD Council of Governments regional land use and transportation plans.
The approach is to get experts together, identify hazards, areas of biological sensitivity, and economic considerations. Then PlaceMatters worked with local partners to engage the community to come up with an actual plan based on the science. The team hosted a Tools Expo in April of 2008 in South Carolina that brought together regional decision-makers and colleagues who could provide new methods to achieve town goals. As the BCD process goes forward, feedback from stakeholders will be provided via an interactive website that provides feedback to the planning process.
Some key lessons learned and successes in the project to date include:
· Creation of a Local Project Implementation Team. This team connected PlaceMatters staff with local experts on biodiversity, sources of hazard data, as well as acting as liaison with local partner organizations.
· Biodiversity Expert Group. Initial outreach to biodiversity experts to ask for assistance in gathering data was challenging. Eventually, a group was gathered for one afternoon to collectively determine conservation goals and discuss available data.
Some key tools, used by the firm PlaceMatters, are:
· CommunityViz to analyze various social and economic impacts and create a future build-out scenario
· NatureServe Vista to analyze performance of the current conditions and two future scenarios with respect to conservation goals
· NOAA’s Community Resilience and Vulnerability Assessment Tool to analyze hazard risk with respect to vulnerable populations and facilities
The results of the scenario analysis will be shared with the BCD COG and its consultant team in order to successfully integrate this information into the public engagement and planning process.
Project Website: www.resilient-communities.org
--Jacob Smith
Jacob Smith, is a PlaceMatters-Packard Fellow based in Denver, Colorado
* PlaceMatters is an organization that helps citizens visualize and shape the impact of development and changes in land use upon their communities, operating as a 501c3 organization. This section of the Internal Revenue Code denotes an officially recognized, American, not for profit organization.
Monday, May 31, 2010
Summer Silent Film Festival - Sustainable means more than Kilowatts
Community that plays together, stays together: sustainability through cultureOutdoor film screenings are the stuff of summer love, all over the world.
For Summer Cinema in Bonn, Germany, it’s a little different. George Clooney won’t play this summer, but rather … Charlie Chaplin.
A Silent Film Festival of this sort exists nowhere else in the world.
For eleven days each August, locals gather beneath the stars and attend the Bonn Summer Silent Film Festival a “Screen on the green” of sorts. Within the large courtyard at the University of Bonn, community happens. Each night, as the twilight comes, a surprise dawns on the crowd: “I didn’t think silent films were so entertaining!” whispers the murmur through the audience. Once beloved but now forgotten stars of 1920s Hollywood, (and their European, Mexican, Korean or Japanese counterparts) grace the screen once again.
In the early age of film making, lack of sound technology demanded creativity on the part of directors and actors. Subtitles carried the stories. Expressive faces were a must. Slapstick humor went far.
2010 marks the 26th season of the Bonn Silent Film Festival. For 10 nights in mid August, at 9pm, a crowd of 1500 movie goers sit in open air, regardless of weather, to watch films. Shorts of 10 minutes, as well as features 120 minutes long play. Some are black and white. Others showcase the early days of color. Known and unknown films and actors share the screen. Not a person falls asleep.
Professional silent film musicians (there are such) improvise accompanying music, live. A piano, violin, and drums provide themes of suspense, victory, and romance. The audience sits in folding chairs before a giant sixteen by twenty-two foot screen. Experienced film goers know to bring an umbrella or light blanket in case -- the program runs rain or shine.
A single curator selects the films to feature during the program. Archival film libraries offer the films for such festivals. The array of films is characterized by diverse genres, lengths, languages and origin countries.
Despite the cost, there is no entry fee. Bonn Film Culture Organization (Förderverein Filmkultur Bonn) believes that, “Film is relevant for the larger public, regardless of income level,” according to Sigrid Limprecht, of the Förderverein Filmkultur Bonn. The City of Bonn, and the State in which it resides, provide half the funding; the other half comes from donations, concessions and sponsorships. The University of Bonn donates the space.
The popular event inevitably leaves a line of late comers without a seat. Local politicians pick the summer film event as a place to network, greet their constituents, and if appropriate, make a speech! A mixed demographic is also drawn: the elderly sit beside the young. In 2009 more than 22,000 people attended over the 10 day event.
Even if not all fall in love with their neighbor, they surely will fall in love with silent film.
www.film-ist-kultur.de/sommerkino/
Friday, April 9, 2010
Maximize a budget to get a lot done
Your lovin' give me a thrill
But your lovin' don't pay my bill.
Now gimme money
But your lovin' don't pay my bill.
Now gimme money
That's what I want!
– The Beatles
Money is what most of us want. Recent hardships call for a different tune, so could old fashioned cooperation leverage a city budget better? The Beatles’ hometown proved it. Liverpool, England offers frugal budgets everywhere a guide.
The headline “Our City, Our Planet,” is shorthand for Liverpool’s push during 2009 to engage the public in improving town’s environmental sustainability. During the Year of the Environment the City of Liverpool hosted more than 900 events with environmental themes. Flower and vegetable shows, bird box making, compost giveaways, a bike tour between churches (Cycle4Faith), and “Zen and the Art of the Wildflower,” were among formal programs. The public events were not lectures about the carbon cycle, so much as community bicycling and mushroom gathering. Mini-grants of around 500-1000£ were awarded to improve neighborhoods around environmental themes: citizens created hundreds of hanging flower baskets, cleaned up their streets, and practiced EcoYoga. Response to the call for grant applications so overwhelmed staff a new position was created to liaise with the public.
City staff scoured department budgets for existing funds upon which Year of the Environment could piggyback. Staff time, marketing, webdesign, surveys, city clean ups all came from reallocating existing budget and employee priorities. The total budget for the year of programming was £1.03; more than £85,000 of in-kind contributions were contributed. The Chamber of Commerce, various neighborhood organizations, the Art Council and wider Liverpool Community Network underwrote other pieces of the Year.
“To know that we were running alongside other people for a year was helpful,” said Christine Darbyshire, of Liverpool City Council, on the value of officially naming 2009 the Year of the Environment. As well, the year-long focus provided “an opportunity to accelerate our collective progress toward becoming a low carbon city,” according to official documents.
Partnership included:
– The Green Ambassador program featured schools, businesses and citizens publically committed to personal change
– A first-time event called the Green Power Forum brought architects, builders, real estate professionals together for a training on green building and renewable energy.
– November’s £120 per plate annual Chamber of Commerce gala featured Marks & Spencer chief executive Sir Stuart Rose as a guest speaker. M&S, a household brand in Britain, has pledged 100 commitments to become carbon neutral, send no waste to the landfill and improve sustainable sourcing.
– The Liverpool Echo newspaper wrote a weekly feature about green activities in the City.
Unfortunately, some Liverpool neighborhoods suffered from multiple indicators of deprivation with low employment, poor health and a degraded physical infrastructure. In light of this, referencing environment in terms of sustainability or more compost would neglect residents’ more pressing need: cleanliness and beauty.
Thus, Liverpool focused on basics: all major supermarkets were tasked with collecting abandoned grocery carts blighting the City. Neighborhood clean ups were held. Seven new bike cycling routes were added in an initiative called “Cycle Speke,” to provide access to employment for residents of this historically poor corner of Liverpool. The Art Council Cultural Investment Program produced a film called “Mend and Make Do” wherein people “explore, remember and relearn skills of a bygone era when recycling was something all did naturally.”
To understand the context of Liverpool’s initiatives, know that the City had long suffered a reputation as a poor city, with high crime rates and antisocial behavior. Unemployment was among the highest in the UK during the 1980s. But regeneration abounds. The European Capital of Culture was bestowed on Liverpool in 2008. Large wind turbines, recently erected, grace the coastline. The most common comment heard is, “You won’t believe how much town has changed!”
The City hopes visitors and investors could be drawn to Liverpool as an environmental showcase, forgetting the image of a brawling and rusty port. “We think the environmental strengths of the city and its natural resources will ultimately be how the city turns itself around” said Darbyshire.
Year of the Environment site:
http://www.ourcityourplanet.org.uk/
Thursday, April 1, 2010
How can land use planning save lives and property? Reduce risk of natural hazards by making a map
Practically speaking, what does climate change look like?
In many cases, natural catastrophes.
However, good planning can reduce the expensive and dangerous effects of large floods, high stormwater, increased tornados, rockfalls, avalanches, mudslides, and treefall across roadways.
The Swiss Federal Office of Spatial Planning has responded to increasingly frequent natural hazards with planning: Switzerland mandated that each of its 3,000 municipalities draft a comprehensive natural hazard map.
The maps identify where potential risks like rockslides, or floods might occur. The data comes from both professional hydrologists, engineers, and through historical news accounts of past disasters. Even elderly residents were solicited for their memories about past avalanches or floods. With this data, decision makers and planners can employ a risk assessment matrix, which charts the intensity of the effect vs. probability of the risk within given zones in a community.
The cost to develop a natural hazard map is shared 40-40-20, with the Swiss federal government and Cantons (Swiss states) each paying 40%, and towns covering the last 20% of the costs to prepare the hazard maps. The timeline for researching and drafting the natural hazard maps runs from 2009-2011. So far more than 60% of communities have finished. Towns who fail to complete the maps may face fines.
What does a natural hazard map look like? Color-coded zones indicate where mudslides, rockfall, avalanches or floods are likely within the community. Identifying the zones forms the rationale behind discouraging development in sensitive areas (though property owners still have final say), or even authorizing municipal planners to deny building permits in areas of high risk to human life.
The maps start a town conversation about emergency response. Bern, Switzerland experienced deadly floods in 2004 when the Rhine River overflowed its banks. Now Bern has an emergency system in place to alert citizens living at the banks, via text message, that a flash flood is impending.
The village of Pontresina constructed a massive rock wall to protect the road and village property from frequent rockfall that results from melting permafrost. Other mountain towns installed traffic lights on sensors to stop traffic when rockfall occurs. Nationwide, Switzerland prioritized educating planners and design professionals (architects, builders, engineers) about natural hazards. Professionals can then mediate landowners’ concerns and prevent problems before they occur.
The also Swiss launched PLANAT. This is a natural hazard working group and website resource that provides tactics to respond to the host of natural disasters induced by climate change. Available in English:
http://www.planat.ch/index.php?userhash=120494600&l=e&nav=1,1,1,1
Another natural hazards platform is operated by the Alpine Convention:
http://www.alpconv.org/theconvention/conv06_WG_c_en.htm
Global scale:
Because of the claims burden natural hazards pose to insurance companies is so large, unstable climatic conditions are expensive. Munich RE opened a “NatCat” or Natural Catastrophe division in 1979, and penned a report warning the industry of the risk exposure posed by climate change.
In 2009, the total number of destructive natural hazards recorded was above the long term average: 850 natural catastophies occured, whereas 770 events reflect the ten year average. Approximately 75,000 deaths per year are attributed to weather-related natural hazards. “In particular, the trend towards an increase in weather-related catastrophes continues, whilst there has fundamentally been no change in the risk of geophysical events such as earthquakes", said Prof. Peter Höppe, Head of Munich Re’s Geo Risks Research department.
http://www.munichre.com/en/media_relations/press_releases/2009/2009_12_29_press_release.aspx
Gareth Thomas, the British International Development Minister backed by a recent Oxfam study, said that by 2015 the number of people who will need to be rescued from natural catastrophes “will rise by more than 100 million as more hurricanes, typhoons, floods and mudslides triggered by climate change add to the toll caused by earthquakes and manmade disasters.” (“Un Will Struggle To Cope with Tide of Natural Disasters, Warns Minister” Guardian, March 29th 2010.)
Specific mitigation measures could include:
· Physical protection directly on individual buildings
· Avalanche Control
· Building rockfall protection nets, mountain flood locks or protective shelters
· Disseminating instructions to the public: how to secure an oil tank and prevent explosions, evacuating the home or office promptly
· Developing a hydrogeological basis for land-use planning and watershed management
· Improving the financing of flood warning systems, and therefore broaden their implementation
· Altering the town building code for heightened electrical security in case of floods
· Ensuring that sloped driveways or access roads can be passed by emergency response vehicles
· Increasing the setback from a ridgeline for new homes or buildings
· Physical protection directly on individual buildings
· Avalanche Control
· Building rockfall protection nets, mountain flood locks or protective shelters
· Disseminating instructions to the public: how to secure an oil tank and prevent explosions, evacuating the home or office promptly
· Developing a hydrogeological basis for land-use planning and watershed management
· Improving the financing of flood warning systems, and therefore broaden their implementation
· Altering the town building code for heightened electrical security in case of floods
· Ensuring that sloped driveways or access roads can be passed by emergency response vehicles
· Increasing the setback from a ridgeline for new homes or buildings
Friday, February 26, 2010
Delivery: Use the Bike
From ordering-in pizza, to the daily newspaper, to the milkman, home delivery systems are an historic part of commerce. While dare-devil bike couriers are common in many metropolitan cities, could the courier service be transferred to other sectors and environments?Like mailing a letter?
The average postal mail carrier in Germany delivers 7000 letters a week. On a bike.
Despite an average rainfall of 80 inches per year, cold temperatures, and a winter with diminished daylight (Berlin lies at 52º N), there are 26,000 bikes in the Deutsche Post mail delivery fleet. It is not uncommon for the bike’s saddle bags, full of mail, to weigh 132 pounds. Since 1896, Germans have used bikes for standard mail delivery; it is also common in Austria and Switzerland.
For delivery routes in hilly areas, the Deutsche Post fleet now includes electric bikes that travel about 14 mph.
Die Deutsche Post, the German mail authority, has established the goal of a 30% reduction in delivery-related emissions by 2020. Reducing fuel consumption is king. So, of the 54,000 mail delivery employees, about 50% use bikes to bring the 71 million letters per week to their recipients. Customers may also mail individual letters with a carbon offset.
The bikes, equipped with transport bags, extra stabilizers, and a lock, cost about 500€.They are expected to last between 4 and 8 years. The average delivery route spans between 6- 18 miles (10 to 30 kilometers). The bikes are maintained by a mobile technician, who operates within a broad region. One of the manufacturing companies Deutsche Post patronizes is called Sachsen Zweirad.
German pharmacies and pizza joints employ bike deliverers too. According to the Hamburg-based national franchise, Joey’s Pizza, bike delivery is a question of efficiency: for a short distance, bikes can deliver a hot pizza faster.
Back to the milkman. A friend who earned his childhood pocket money helping the milkman, discovered a secret about community fabric. It was the milkman who recognized that an accumulation of still full milk bottles on Old Mrs. Smith’s front porch signaled something amiss. Personal, daily delivery services are a small and essential part of the relationships that give us community. Moving past one another at a slower pace and a quieter level could reveal a clue into the sort of interactions which keep us whole.
For Deutsche Post's Sustainability Report:
http://www.dp-dhl.com/en/responsibility.html
For images of historic bike delivery, German text
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postfahrrad
Bike delivery by the USPS
http://www.usps.com/green/report/2008/Our_Environment3.html
Wednesday, January 27, 2010
School Weatherization Funding Strategy

Ask more of your janitor, ask more of the 5th grader, and then ask them to work together.
An initiative in Germany, called 50/50, motivates students to transform the energy profile of their schools. The changes are modest and realistic. The methods of conservation are traditional and inexpensive. But they pay. If a school can decrease its annual energy needs by at least 10%, the savings is split in half between the students and the school district.
The average participating school saves 100 MW of heating, 10,000 kWh of electricity, 40T of CO2 and earns 5,000€ (when a total of 10,000€ in energy costs was saved).
Students and janitors work as a team. Five to ten students tour their school with the janitor and an energy auditor. Together they develop a plan for implementation, and then communicate the plan to the rest of the school with creative messages. The school pays for cheap investments like a boiler blanket. Any larger investment requests are submitted to the school district, but large investments like new windows are not actually the point.
“We really want to focus on user behavior,” said Almuth Tharan, of the Unabhängiges Institut für Umweltfragen (UfU) e.V., one of the national project coordinators.
One hundred and fifty schools in Berlin participate in the program. Annually, the 50/50 program saves €600,000 citywide. With a population of 3 million, the 150 participating schools represent just ¼ of all schools who could participate. The program is nearly 20 years old.
50/50 is just one piece of energy and resource education. In German schools this begins at an early age. Students are taught solar energy and resource conservation through a variety of locally developed curriculum measures. Pre-fab kits are widely deployed. An energy suitcase with a digital thermometer and a light meter help 5th graders learn measurement and graphing. “Renewables in a Box,” brings big concepts to even small pupils: the Sunshine Suitcase visits Kindergartners too.
To learn more about 50/50 in Germany: http://www.ufu.de/media/content/files/UfU_Englisch/Climate_Protection/Fifty-fifty_Energy_Education.pdf
Wednesday, January 20, 2010
Renault: Driving the Change
"Has there ever been a finer creation than the automobile?
"But is it still in tune with society today? Is it acceptible that some of us are able to drive while others barely have the means to get around? Why should making the most of our lives today imply a lower quality of life tomorrow? Does enjoyment for some have to cost the lives of others? Do you still have to be one of the lucky few to reap the benefits of progress?"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pm1Bb0H8QCs&feature=related
"Has there ever been a finer creation than the automobile?
"But is it still in tune with society today? Is it acceptible that some of us are able to drive while others barely have the means to get around? Why should making the most of our lives today imply a lower quality of life tomorrow? Does enjoyment for some have to cost the lives of others? Do you still have to be one of the lucky few to reap the benefits of progress?"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pm1Bb0H8QCs&feature=related
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



